Home › Forums › Archives › Community Center › Forum Support › Bug Reports › Squashed Bugs › Staff Room › Oh how I long for the day when this happens…
- This topic has 1 reply, 2 voices, and was last updated 18 years, 5 months ago by
Doris Kenney.
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 13, 2008 at 1:34 am #28922
Jeff Hester
KeymasterI know BigBlueBall is nothing like Slashdot in size or scope, but oh how I long for the day when we might have dialog like this discussion about IM productivity in the workplace.
We also ran a story sourced from ScienceDaily on the same topic, but without the discussion.
Part of this is a function of the volume of active members, but I’d love to see even a little bit more of the Slashdot-style conversations.
Anyone got any ideas on how to get from here to there? :confused:
June 13, 2008 at 4:03 am #170053Doris Kenney
ParticipantOK Jeff, you asked and I’m gonna cut loose on this one! (You may be sorry you posed the question – but more likely that I bothered to answer LOL!)
I don’t frequent Slashdot, but a quick glance at the home page tells me they are quite far more diverse than BBB. BBB is a a niche forum. Unless someone has a problem with instant messaging, very few people likely to stumble onto the site just to see what it is. And only those members who have stuck around long enough to check out other forums would likely consider us for other types of topics. Diversifying would increase the liklihood of more people finding us…which could, with a lot of nurturing and trial and error, get you to the desired level.
Quite honestly, the name BBB is poised perfectly for it! It doesn’t tie into any one specific area and implies the boundlessness of technology. I don’t know what kind of search engine optimization you’ve done, but a quick glance at the meta tags on the home page would lead me to believe that if I searched for something in one of the non-IM related forums I’d be unlikely to see BBB at the top of the list. And unless I were a frequent visitor, I wouldn’t get my “news” from BBB. (Sheepish grin – I don’t have BBB in my Google Reader because quite frankly the headlines are not fresh enough, rapid enough, or diverse enough.) I fully realize the search engines go far beyond meta tags these days, but in and of itself ours say we limit ourselves in the potential for growth. Interestingly, go take a look at the meta tags on Slashdot’s homepage. I didn’t find any. Either they pay one hell of a lot for optimization, or they just don’t see themselves as having limits. (Or perhaps some combination of the two.)
To get the membership for that kind of lenghty discourse means we have to be the place people want to come for anything geekily newsworthy (and/or to have a bit of fun.) At the moment, we are primarily a place to solve specific problems – then it seems most members move on. I’m curious – do you have any stats on how many members have posted less than 10 times? 50 times? What percentage of our membership is actually coming back again and again… and yet again? And are the majority of our members of the “quality” that will be able to engage in a diverse conversation? Certainly we have quite a few staff members capable of that level of engaging “conversation” but many of our members can’t phrase a clear question! Unless readers and posters are able to take criticism (constructive or otherwise), and not feel threatened by differing opinions, you won’t get the interesting and thought provoking mix Slashdot does.
I’ve purposely stayed out of the frequent discussions on updating our look, but I’m going to voice my opinion this one time (and likely only this one time.) Our look is outdated and does not project the image of a top notch site. We have the old school forum look. And that’s what we are – forums. Slashdot is certainly a “canned” type format, but at least they’ve prettied it up with different color schemes on different pages, using a very bloglike interface. But read on…there could be a meshing of the two that’s workable in my mind.
From what I see, Slashdot is user driven in terms of articles. Much like Lifehacker. Our users are question posers for the most part. They expect the “IM only news” is just gonna show up on the front page. You want that interaction? You’ll have to give them the urge to post their own news – and as long as what they post is not objectionable – and it needs to be with minimal censorship (except the spam of course). What you are wanting to attract is not just members – but mini-bloggers. Lord knows they’re out there, you just have to make them want to come here.
I’m not suggesting the forums are not useful or an integral part of BBB. There help provided here is certainly the best in terms of instant messaging. And in fact, forums specifically for help, and postings specifically for the purpose of engaging conversation would be a wonderful mix. It would be a mix that many sites don’t offer. They tend to be one or the other, but I believe (with a little out of the box vision) you could successfully integrate the two. (That’s where the forum look stays forum – it inherently implies assistance to a lot of people – and a new updated look for a conversation/article driven part of BBB could be integrated.)
But what you are asking for is not how we get more people to ask questions. You’ve asked how we shift the nature of BBB to conversations. Perhaps it’s time for a good think as to the direction of BBB, and where IM (which I know is near and dear to your heart and should always be a part of BBB just for that reason) fits in the big picture. I for one already blog on a number of sites (from my own personal ones to those that are geared towards specific areas – and yes I am capable of writing less than a short novel when I put my mind to it – I just had a lot to say tonight). I know a number of other staff and members also are bloggers on any number of interesting and diverse (and quite conversation worthy) topics. I’m quite sure there are enough of us around to get the Big Blue Ball rolling (pun intended). I’d be willing to bet we all find sites/articles of interest everyday – they just don’t fit into BBB and Instant Messaging. (AND they can’t be posted to BBB with LiveWriter LOL!)
But unless you are ready and willing to make that shift to a different format for that type of discourse and engagement, I’m not entirely sure you can get to that level with the forum structure we have now.
Bet you’re sorry you asked eh? I’m gonna shut up now (finally!)
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.